23 Italian Restaurants In NEW YORK (Yummy, Tasty & Superb)
It is well known worldwide that Italians cook up some of the best meals with flavourful ingredients.
But do you know you don’t have to go to Italy to get a plate of Italian delicacies?
From creamy pasta to fresh pizza to baked lasagna, New York has the best Italian restaurants that offer plenty of options to satisfy your cravings.
Maybe you want to enjoy a plate of pasta after a long day at work, or you are looking for a fancy spot to have a romantic dinner; New York has them in abundance.
Each restaurant has a unique vibe and ambiance for a great time.
Below, you will find some of the exceptional Italian restaurants in New York that will have you returning for more.
And by the way, you may also want to check out the best Seafood Restaurants in New York.
Italian Restaurants in Manhattan, New York
1. Carmine’s Italian Restaurant In Times Square.
If you crave good southern Italian cuisine, visit this place in Manhattan.
Apart from the location in Times Square, they have other outlets all over New York City.
To get to Carmine’s, drive to Times Square, two blocks from the 42nd Street subway station.
The food is delicious, and the ambiance and dining experience you enjoy is exceptional.
Suppose you want an Italian feast with your family.
In that case, this is your go-to, as the restaurant gives you that homemade sensation.
Platters of pasta, antipasto, seafood, ravioli, lasagna, and more are available to share with friends and family.
What’s better than bonding before a large feast of Italian delicacy?
The place gets quite busy since people know they will enjoy the food, so make reservations before your visit.
Address: 200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
2. Masseria Dei Vini
This restaurant near Lincoln Center is well known for its special delicacies.
The Chefs here put together a delectable menu of traditional and modern dishes just for you.
Most dishes on the menu feature meals from Puglia in South Italy.
They have Crudo, a fish and shellfish meal, homemade pasta, ravioli, and gourmet pizza.
You can also have other dishes like salmon, salad, chicken, and prawns.
Although their extensive wine selection features bottles from Italy, you would also find some from other parts of the world.
For dessert, although they offer chocolate almond cake, cheesecake, and others, the tiramisu is one of the customer’s favorites because it is served fresh and delicious.
The service and hospitality here are fantastic; you are back for more before you know it.
Address: 887 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, United States
3. Trattoria Trecolori
The family-owned Italian restaurant is in the middle of the theatre district in Downtown Manhattan.
They have a comfortable space where they deliver satisfying and mouth-watering dishes to customers from all over New York.
You must try the classic antipasto meal if you love shrimp and mushrooms.
If you are dining as a group, you can order from the menu set up for family or buffet service.
Apart from their delicious meals, they have a lengthy wine list you may not find in other restaurants.
It has two sections, Italian and International where you can pick your choice of wine to step down with your meal.
You can also have private dining and intimate celebrations on the second floor with a lounge and bar.
The spot is quite bustling, so contact them before you show up for the perfect experience.
Address: 254 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
4. Scarpetta
Scarpetta, when dining, is an Italian expression that means to soak up all the sauce on your plate with bread.
That’s the experience you enjoy when you visit this restaurant
You can savor flavorful Italian dishes down to the last taste and bite.
Spaghetti, ravioli, bread, steak, and short ribs are popular items on the menu.
The environment is welcoming and has a chic vibe to it.
Apart from the bar and cafe, there is an enclosed patio overlooking the street of Manhattan, while the main dining area is at the rear of the restaurant.
The interior is designed in an open-air setting with retractable glass windows and hardwood floors, bringing tons of natural light into the space.
The venue can seat up to 125 guests, which makes it a perfect spot for any celebration, whether birthdays, anniversaries, or corporate events.
Make a date at Scarpetta as soon as possible.
You will surely soak up all the sauce on your plate!
Address: 88 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States
5. La Masseria NY
This spot in the theater district is designed with rustic elements to imitate a farmhouse in Puglia.
The restaurant stands out with its stone-clad walls, beams in the ceiling, and wooden textures.
Meals like burrata, pasta with clams, ravioli filled with ricotta cheese, and other rich and cream-filled delicacies are available here.
The menu not only incorporates meals from Puglia but also from other parts of Italy.
When in doubt as to the perfect choice of dessert, have a slice of tiramisu.
It’s like having a taste of Italy while in New York.
The 250 wine list offers some of the best Italian flavors, with few from America and other parts of the world.
There is something for everyone to enjoy on that wine list.
Take your taste buds to Italy by visiting La Masseria in Manhattan, New York.
Address: 235 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
6. Angelleto
Experience the taste of fresh homemade pasta and other Italian delicacies made with the best ingredients.
You will find this restaurant around the turtle bay area in Manhattan’s Middle East of Manhattan.
The ambiance, in three words, would be classy, homey, and spacious.
All tables are covered in white clothes to give that homey yet romantic vibe.
They also have an outdoor sitting area to enjoy your meal outside the main dining area.
Staffs are friendly and ready to give you excellent service.
From appetizers to salads to soups, pasta, risotto, other side dishes, and wine, they have all you need to enjoy a traditional Italian meal.
Aside from Italian dishes, they also serve superb Roman meals.
After a long, draining day, stop by and let them fill your glass with your preferred fine wine or cocktail selection.
Address: 890 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10017, United States
Also see our article on Chinese Restaurants in New York.
Italian Restaurants in Schenectady, New York
1. The Appian Way
Enjoy perfectly made steaks, prawns, spaghetti, and veal here at Appian Way.
They also make delicious gelato available if you have a sweet tooth.
Pastas, bread, and gnocchi are all made from scratch and served fresh and yummy!
Ingredients such as basil, peppers, tomatoes, beet beans, and lettuce are all sourced from their garden.
All of this is in a small cozy space, but the flavor and ambiance here are second to none!
The setting and decoration are perfect for a family outing.
Although they only offer dine-in services, you will surely enjoy your money and time.
However, they provide catering services for birthdays, weddings, or holiday celebrations.
The menu is specially curated for every taste, budget, and style!
You can check out the menu and other information on their website.
Address: 1839 Van Vranken Ave., Schenectady, NY 12308, United States
2. Scotti’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
One thing that is of utmost priority at this restaurant is the flavor and appearance of your food.
This gem on upper union street used to be a small pizza spot and now serves one of the best Italian dishes in the city.
They have a wide selection of dishes on the menu.
You can have veal Gaetano which includes veal made with prosciutto, fresh lemon, and mozzarella served with spinach.
They have other Italian specialties like chicken Sorrento, chicken white wine, eggplant rollatini, and more!
All entrees are with steamed broccoli or pasta.
If seafood is what you would like, they have options from shrimps to calamari to clams and tender squid.
They also offer full catering services for social and corporate events.
If you have yet to visit Scotti’s, what are you waiting for?
Address: 1730 Union Street, No 4, Schenectady, NY 12309, United States
3. Johnny’s
Johnny’s is a casual dining area in the heart of downtown Schenectady.
It has both indoor and outdoor dining areas.
The restaurant is committed to bringing family, fun, and food in one package.
They offer a wide range of delicious options; whether it’s a romantic dinner date, a group of friends hanging out, a family celebration, or a corporate outing, there is something for everyone.
Freshly made pizza, sandwiches, nachos, pasta, meatballs, ravioli, and more are all available to order at Johnny’s.
The food is yummy, the atmosphere is calm, and the service is incredible.
Fresh Italian meals go well with a glass of cocktail or wine, so get one or two.
What are you waiting for?
Check out their menu and get yourself a plate of Italian goodness.
Buon Appetito!
Address: 433 State St, Schenectady, NY 12305, United States.
4. MORE Perreca’s
All meals here have delectable seasonings and are rich in flavor.
This restaurant has been owned and managed by the same family for over 106 years!
How impressive is that?
They offer seafood options like shrimp, mussels, calamari, scallops, and more!
Try spaghetti with meatballs, chicken parmesan, pasta, pizza, lasagna, and chicken piccata.
They have a bakery opposite the kitchen, so you can be sure of freshly made bread.
Customers have rated the bread rather famously as their best.
And, oh, the dessert options are suited to every taste and preference.
They also have a wide selection of local and Italian wines and beers.
Order online or make reservations and enjoy the yummy Italian cuisine served at Perreca’s.
Address: 31 N Jay St, Schenectady, NY 12305, United States
Also see our article on Happy Hours in New York.
Italian Restaurants in Saratoga Springs, New York
1. Chianti II Ristorante
The setting is elegant, with locally sourced ingredients and top-notch meals.
Anything Northern Italian recipe and cuisine you can have all here at Chianti.
The menu is regularly modified to give you new and flavorful recipes.
You can have grilled or toasted ciabatta bread with oven-roasted tomatoes and grana panado.
Yummy right?
That’s not all, though.
For dessert, they offer assortments of gelato and sorbet or tiramisu.
Drinks are also available, with many options for cocktails and wine.
You can also eat on the outdoor patio beside the main dining area.
Servers and Bartenders are friendly and ready to help to ensure you have the best experience the restaurant offers.
Indulge yourself with a plate of Italian goodness whenever you find yourself in the heart of Downtown Saratoga Springs.
Address: 18 Division Street, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866, United States
2. Osteria Danny
The menus change with the chef’s season, ingredients, and mood.
Regardless, everything offered here looks and tastes fantastic.
To get to this restaurant, drive to Henry Street, and you will find it just two blocks away from Saratoga Race Course.
They offer free Wi-Fi, outdoor seating, and a full bar.
You can take out or make reservations ahead of time.
The Chef, Danny, makes his meals with locally sourced ingredients that are served hot and fresh.
Servers treat customers with respect and are attentive to details and concerns.
So If you are unsure what will appear on your table when you order, ask the servers.
They know the menu like the back of their hands and would gladly help.
Everything on the menu is a hit.
What are you waiting for?
Visit this restaurant and have food galore!
Address: 26 Henry St, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866, United States
3. Solevo Kitchen
All menu options here are made from scratch and reflect different ingredients.
One remarkable fact about this restaurant is that the menu contains recipes passed down through the Chefs of the Solevo family.
While many of the recipes are generations old, the owners have been able to keep up with modern times and craft the best Italian dishes.
There are many options of dishes from spaghettI with clams to gnocchi, salmon, Parmigiano, lasagna, scampi, and more!
They serve some of the best meatballs and pasta in Saratoga Springs.
Other popular dishes include lasagna, gnocchi, lobster pasta, shrimp pasta, veal chop, bolognese pasta, and eggplant chips.
The Solevos family has created a name for themselves in the world of elegant Italian delicacies.
They also have cocktails and wine, whether white, rose, or red.
Visit Solevo Kitchen and discover what makes them unique in the city.
Address: 55 Phila St, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866, United States
4. Pennel’s Kitchen
The kitchen’s appetizer, entree, pasta, and dessert are rich in flavor and love.
Penney’s kitchen is on Jefferson Street, within walking distance from Wilton Mall.
This hidden gem serves some of the finest Italian dishes you can imagine.
The greet scampi, veal, lasagna, shrimp, haddock, and meatballs are some of their popular dishes.
Their homemade salad dressing and rich sauces are some of the best in town.
You can take away your meal or experience fine dining in the restaurant.
The place is comfortable and cozy, so it is advisable to enjoy and experience fine dining.
There is also a lovely covered patio outside the restaurant in case you want a casual and
Besides delicious meals, they have cocktails, beer, coffee, alcohol, and wine.
Make your choice!
Call the restaurant to make your reservations and taste yummy Italian cuisine.
Address: 284 Jefferson St, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866, United States
Also see our article on Coffee Shops in New York.
Italian restaurants in Rochester, New York
1. Osteria Rocco
This restaurant is near the popular attraction site, the Strong National Museum of Play on Monroe Avenue in Rochester.
The large floor-to-ceiling windows give you a beautiful view of the city while you dine and wine in the restaurant.
You can eat at the lounge or bar with a glass of any beverage.
Some of their special dishes include ricotta with charred bread, bruschetta con Polpette, and well-cooked pork.
And the pizza is one of the tastiest in the city, with two particular flavors being most customers’ go-to the crumbled lamb and pepperoni.
The atmosphere, in two words, would be cozy and intimate.
They also have a lovely outdoor patio with a water feature if you prefer to have a meal there.
Osteria Rocco is one of the best old-school restaurants in Rochester, New York.
Address: 165 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
2. Ristorante Lucano
They serve top-notch Southern and Italian cuisines made with the finest ingredients.
Although the meals are a bit pricey when it comes to one of the best menu options, Lucano takes the cake!
Not only do they offer delicious Italian dishes, but they also have other cuisines like seafood, continental, and Mediterranean.
The Italian menu includes antipasti, primi piatti, second piatti,
You can have the yummy gelato or the dessert platter, which includes all their best desserts in one place, perfect for a family outing.
You can also pick out a bottle of wine to pair with any of the dinner options available.
Stop by during happy hour to enjoy complimentary drink specials while mingling with everyone.
It is always a lovely time!
Why not drop by this place if you crave a good Italian meal?
Address: 1815 East Ave, Rochester, NY 14610, United States
3. Grappa Italian Nouveau
They say good food means a good mood and this restaurant gives just that!
Italian Nouveau is a perfect place to have a romantic dinner, a night out with friends, or a little celebration with family.
You will find this trendy spot on the ground floor of Hilton Garden Inn opposite the Strong Hospital.
They have managed to craft traditional Italian cuisines in a modern and flavorful way.
The atmosphere here is classy and exquisite.
If you want a private dining area, they have one, Camera Piccola.
It’s a good spot for intimate family celebrations, private dinners, and cocktail receptions, and it seats up to 18 people.
They have you covered if you want a custom menu to meet every taste and style.
Head over to Italian Nouveau for a fine dining experience!
Address: 30 Celebration Dr, Rochester, NY 14620, United States
Also see our article on Desserts in New York.
Italian Restaurants in Queens, New York
1. Il Poeta
The chef here, Mario Di Chiara, knows how to cook up tasty Northern Italian cuisines that you cannot help but stop by every time.
You will surely have a swell time with the table-clothed setting and homey and comfortable vibes.
Luca, the owner, and the Chef, Mario, are accommodating and friendly to their customers.
Some popular items on the menu include Nutella cheesecake, crostata battuta, penne, baked clams, and mussels.
White wine from Northern Italy is not a bad option at all.
Do not leave without tasting some heavenly dessert that will surely melt and leave a sweet flavor on your buds all day.
Tiramisu, strawberry dessert, and panna cotta are good options to have.
If you live in the forest hills area or plan to take a trip to Queens, New York, anytime soon, visit Il Poeta to experience exquisite Italian food.
Address: 98-04 Metropolitan Ave, Queens, NY 11375, United States
2. Park Side.
A stroll down Corona Avenue is a historic Italian American Restaurant in New York City.
With glitzy and elegant decorations, this restaurant’s menu holds most recipes from Sicily and Northern Italy.
The ambiance and atmosphere at this restaurant are a ten out of ten.
Their main menu offers Italian and seafood dishes such as chicken parmigiana, veal masala, lobster tail, baked clams, pasta primavera, and many more.
You can also find vegetarian, gluten-free, and vegan options on the menu
For your private celebrations and intimate dinners like birthdays, anniversaries, and graduation parties, they have a private dining room available for bookings.
They also offer flexible banquet packages for events.
The Marylyn Monroe Room, the banquet room, accommodates about 50 persons to host exceptional events.
This restaurant is worth a trip to Queens, New York.
Address: 107-01 Corona Ave., Queens, NY 11368, United States
3. Trattoria L’incontro
Trattoria is an upscale restaurant adorned with a white table clothe setting in the Astoria neighborhood of Queens, New York.
Chef Roco Sacramone opened this place in 1999 and has provided guests with a unique dining experience and superb meals ever since.
Although this is one of those places you might not often visit, you are sure to leave with a full belly when you do.
With every stop-by, the experience only gets better and better!
The restaurant uses only fresh ingredients to make both traditional and modern cuisines.
Some of the must haves include the gnocchi, octopus, granzino, ravioli golosi and calamari fritti.
Try out the tiramisu or gelato or pistachio creme brulee for dessert.
It’s worth coming to Trattoria L’incontro if you have never tasted Italian dishes.
Address: 21-76 31st St, Queens, NY 11105, United States
Also see our article on Cooking Classes in New York.
Italian Restaurants in White Plains, New York.
1. Buon Amici Italian Restaurant
The restaurant is welcoming and inviting regardless of whether you are there for lunch, dinner, or a special event.
White clothes adorn the table with wooden textures and light fixtures.
There is an outdoor patio to enjoy your meal while overlooking the street views.
You can host special events like baby showers, birthdays, and anniversaries and try out their catering services.
It will surely exceed your expectations.
They have impressive options on the menu available for you.
Options include baked clams, penne vodka, spaghetti and meatballs, oysters, pasta, and more!
The menu includes dessert and drink options like tiramisu, chocolate rainbow cake, whiskey sour, and champagne.
Buon Amici is open seven days a week.
Come with a big appetite and enjoy a delicious meal!
Address: 238 Central Ave, White Plains, NY 10606, United States
2. Mulino’s of Westchester
It’s always a five-star experience here at Mulino’s.
The restaurant is right in the heart of Westchester County in White Plain, New York.
They serve Northern Italian meals in an elegant and aesthetically pleasing manner.
And the atmosphere?
Enchanting, romantic, and classy.
The wood tones, modern lighting designs, and glass windows add to the impeccable ambiance.
You can have a romantic date with your partner while overlooking the stunning water fountain through the glass windows.
Everyone here is charming and welcoming, from the host to the staff.
You can host private events like holiday gatherings, celebrations with friends and family, or corporate dinners in the private dining room.
The place, the dishes, and the service are all exceptional, and you should experience it yourself.
Address: 99 Court St, White Plains, NY 10601, United States
3. Chazz Palminteri Italian Restaurant.
What do you say about a top-notch meal in an upscale restaurant offering all the Italian comfort you can think of?
Chazz Palminteri offers all of these and more!
The delicious cuisines offered are mainly traditional meals from Italy and Sicily.
Servers present the meals in a mouth-watering and delectable design.
Some of the highlights on the menu include the grilled octopus, meatballs, fried calamari, chicken Francese, lobster ravioli, and creme brulee.
They also offer a fine selection of cocktails, wine, and beverages.
So if you are looking for a spot to have drinks and bond with friends over a plate of yummy food, this is the place.
Dessert here is amazing, with options like red velvet, carrot, chocolate and cheesecakes, tiramisu, sorbet, and ice cream of different flavors.
Enough of drooling!
Visit the restaurant and have a plate to yourself.
Address: 264 Main St, White Plains, NY 10601, United States
If you liked this article, you may also like to read about the best Breweries, Wineries, and Apple Picking Spots in New York.
Looking beyond New York? Check out our article on the best Italian Restaurants in Illinois and California’s finest Italian Restaurants.