23 Consignment Shops in NEW YORK (Stylish, Trusty & Unique)
Welcome to the vibrant world of consignment shopping in New York!
If you are a savvy shopper or a fashion aficionado looking for unique treasures, then this article is your ultimate guide.
With its bustling streets and diverse neighborhoods, New York also offers an array of consignment shops that cater to every taste and budget.
Suppose you are searching for vintage clothing, designer accessories, or one-of-a-kind home decor items.
In that case, this article will provide you with a comprehensive list of 23 consignment shops across New York.
So get ready to indulge in the thrill of hunting for pre-loved treasures in the world’s fashion capital – New York!
And by the way, you may also want to check out the best Hobby Shops in New York.
Consignment Shops in New York City, New York
1. Aptiques
Whether it’s antique toy cars or vintage LV trunks, Aptiques is New York’s go-to consignment shop for all such things.
It is one of the most astonishing antique shops in the city.
Located in a charming corner of the city, this local favorite consignment shop has become famous for its extensive collection of one-of-a-kind items.
Aptiques is not your average consignment shop; it’s an enchanting treasure trove where history comes alive.
Owned by the charismatic Bob, Aptiques offers a delightful shopping experience that takes visitors on a journey through time.
With his keen eye for quality and authenticity, Bob curates an impressive selection of antiques that captivates everyone who walks through his doors.
From rare collectibles to beautiful furniture pieces from different eras, each item tells its own story and adds character to any space.
Address: 461 W Broadway, New York, NY 10012, United States
2. La Boutique Resale Consignments
If you’re a fashion enthusiast with a penchant for high-end designer clothing, accessories, and shoes, look no further than La Boutique Resale Consignments.
It can be considered a haven for high-end fashionistas in New York City.
Nestled in the heart of the city, this bi-level resale store is every stylish woman’s dream come true.
This consignment shop truly has everything from renowned fashion houses like Chanel, Gucci, and Prada to coveted labels such as Christian Louboutin and Louis Vuitton.
Step into La Boutique Resale Consignments and prepare to be amazed by the dazzling array of designer pieces adorning the racks.
With a reputation for curating an impressive collection of luxury brands at affordable prices, this consignment shop has become a go-to destination for those looking to score incredible deals on top-notch fashion.
Address: 1132 Madison Ave 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10028, United States
3. Margoth Consignment Shop
Welcome to Margoth Consignment Shop, the premier consignment shop in New York City.
This shop has low prices and great variety, offering an unparalleled shopping experience for fashionistas and bargain hunters alike.
Whether you are searching for a trendy outfit for a special occasion or simply looking to refresh your wardrobe with unique pieces, Margoth Consignment Shop has got you covered.
This consignment shop is renowned for its incredible selection and very good quality items.
From designer clothing to accessories and shoes, our inventory is carefully curated to cater to every style and budget.
At Margoth Consignment Shop, you can find timeless classics and trendy pieces that will make heads turn wherever you go.
With their commitment to customer satisfaction, the shop staff can take pride in offering top-notch service coupled with unbeatable prices.
Address: 218 E 81st St, New York, NY 10028, United States
4. Matiell Consignment
Looking for a cute boutique-style consignment shop in the heart of New York City?
Then look no further than Matiell Consignment!
Located in bustling streets, this hidden gem offers an incredible selection of designer clothes and accessories at affordable prices.
Whether you’re hunting for that perfect little black dress or a statement handbag, Matiell Consignment has it all.
Its commitment to excellent service and quality sets Matiell Consignment apart from other shops.
The friendly and knowledgeable staff are always ready to assist you in finding exactly what you’re looking for.
With their keen eye for fashion and extensive knowledge of current trends, they can help you create a stylish and unique outfit that truly reflects your style.
Furthermore, every piece at Matiell Consignment undergoes a rigorous inspection to ensure that only top-notch items make it onto their racks.
So why wait?
Address: 163 E 87th St, New York, NY 10128, United States
5. Michael’s, The Consignment Shop for Women
Michael’s, The Consignment Shop for Women, has been a family-owned mainstay in New York City for decades.
Known as a women’s go-to destination for secondhand designer-label fashions and accessories, this consignment shop has built a loyal following among fashion enthusiasts looking to score high-end pieces at affordable prices.
With its prime location in the city’s heart, this store offers a curated selection of gently used clothing, shoes, handbags, and jewelry that cater to all tastes and styles, especially for women.
Its commitment to quality and authenticity sets Michael’s apart from other consignment shops.
They undergo a rigorous inspection process to ensure that every item that passes through their doors meets their strict standards.
Customers can rest assured they purchase genuine designer pieces that have been carefully vetted by knowledgeable staff members passionate about fashion.
Address: 1125 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028, United States
6. The RealReal
The RealReal, a well-established consignment shop in the heart of New York City, offers an unparalleled shopping experience for those seeking high-end fashion at discounted prices.
This consignment shop has revolutionized the way people buy and sell luxury goods.
With 12 locations across the United States and a strong online presence, The RealReal offers an unrivaled selection of luxury items for fashion enthusiasts.
The RealReal has become the go-to destination for fashion-forward individuals looking for unique pieces of clothing and accessories from top brands, thanks to its meticulously curated collection and impeccable customer service.
At The RealReal, buyers can indulge in their passion for designer fashion while saving money by purchasing pre-owned pieces at discounted prices.
This consignment shop caters to every fashionista’s taste, from iconic handbags to statement jewelry and stylish clothing pieces.
Address: 80 Wooster St, New York, NY 10012, United States
7. Tokyo Joe NYC
Looking for a small but charming consignment shop that offers luxury designer pieces and vintage finds?
Then you should consider Tokyo Joe NYC, located in the heart of New York City.
Since opening its doors in 1994, this boutique has become a go-to destination for fashion enthusiasts and bargain hunters.
With an extensive collection of carefully curated items, Tokyo Joe NYC is a treasure trove for those seeking unique and stylish pieces at affordable prices.
One of the standout features of Tokyo Joe NYC is its selection of luxury designers.
This consignment shop offers an impressive range of high-end fashion options, from renowned labels such as Chanel and Gucci to emerging designers making waves in the industry.
Whether you’re on the hunt for a statement handbag or a show-stopping evening gown, Tokyo Joe NYC is sure to have something that catches your eye.
Address: 334 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
Also see our article on Boutiques in New York.
Consignment Shops in Syracuse, New York
1. Cluttered Closet
If you’re searching for a consignment shop with a good selection of new and vintage items, look no further than Cluttered Closet in Syracuse, New York.
This hidden gem offers an extensive range of quality pieces that will satisfy even the most eclectic tastes.
From trendy clothing to unique accessories, this shop has it all.
One of the standout features at Cluttered Closet is their rack of vintage costume items.
Whether you’re searching for a one-of-a-kind Halloween costume or just want to add some flair to your wardrobe, this section is sure to impress.
The carefully curated selection ensures that you’ll find something truly special and eye-catching.
And what’s even better?
All these treasures are available at reasonable prices, so you can score some great stuff without breaking the bank.
Address: 742 S Beech St, Syracuse, NY 13210, United States
2. EcoChic Boutique
EcoChic Boutique, a hidden gem in the heart of Syracuse, New York, is your go-to consignment boutique for all things eco-friendly.
With a wide range of clothing, footwear, and accessories that are both stylish and sustainable, EcoChic offers an unparalleled shopping experience for those who care about the environment.
Step into this relaxed atmosphere and discover a treasure trove of pre-loved fashion pieces that have been carefully curated to meet your eco-conscious needs.
At EcoChic Boutique, you can rest assured that every item you purchase has been thoughtfully selected to minimize its environmental impact.
From ethically sourced fabrics to upcycled materials, the boutique prides itself on stocking items that align with its commitment to sustainability.
Besides, they have a great staff who are always available to assist you, and the products’ prices are also reasonable.
Address: 4314 E Genesee St, Dewitt, NY 13214, United States
3. North Syracuse Consignment
North Syracuse Consignment is a hidden gem in the heart of the city.
This consignment shop stands out from the rest due to its fair prices, ensuring customers can find incredible deals without breaking the bank.
Whether you are searching for clothing, furniture, or home decor items, North Syracuse Consignment guarantees that all pieces are of good quality and in excellent condition.
What sets this consignment shop apart is its selection of unique and one-of-a-kind items.
From vintage clothing to antique furniture, shoppers can discover treasures they won’t find anywhere else.
The store takes pride in offering various options, catering to different tastes and preferences.
Moreover, these exclusive finds are also super affordable, making it an ideal destination for budget-conscious shoppers who still want to add a touch of style and uniqueness to their lives.
Address: 3728 Brewerton Rd, North Syracuse, NY 13212, United States
4. Once Upon A Child
Once Upon A Child, a popular chain operation in Syracuse, New York, offers parents and caregivers the perfect solution for buying and selling gently used items for children.
With a wide selection of clothes, shoes, and toys available at affordable prices, this consignment shop has become a go-to destination for budget-conscious families looking to save money without compromising on quality.
The store’s commitment to providing only top-notch products ensures customers can find stylish outfits and durable toys while minimizing their environmental impact by reusing pre-loved items.
At Once Upon A Child in Syracuse, parents can sell their children’s outgrown clothes and toys for cash or store credit.
This process allows families to declutter their homes and others to purchase these items at discounted rates.
By participating in this circular economy model, shoppers contribute to reducing waste by extending the lifecycle of children’s essentials.
Address: 5775 Bridge St, Syracuse, NY 13057, United States
5. Second Chance Clothing Consignment
Second Chance Clothing Consignment is a hidden gem among the bustling streets of Syracuse, New York.
Nestled in a quaint corner, this small consignment store has become a favorite haunt for fashion enthusiasts looking for new and nearly-new women’s and men’s clothing.
With its impressive collection of stylish apparel, shoes, jewelry, and accessories, Second Chance Clothing Consignment offers an exciting opportunity to revamp your wardrobe without breaking the bank.
Reney, the kind-hearted business owner behind Second Chance Clothing Consignment, has created a unique and welcoming environment for shoppers.
At Second Chance Clothing Consignment, Reney ensures that every customer feels valued and appreciated.
Her warm smile and friendly demeanor make it clear that she genuinely cares about each person who walks through her doors.
Whether you’re on the hunt for designer labels or unique vintage finds, this store has something to suit every taste and budget.
Address: 116 W Manlius St, East Syracuse, NY 13057, United States
Also see our article on Thrift Stores in New York.
Consignment Shops in Saratoga Springs, New York
1. New 2 You Fine Consignment Boutique
Looking for a fun place to shop with wonderful staff and awesome prices?
If the answer is yes, look no further than New 2 You Fine Consignment Boutique, the premier consignment shop in Saratoga Springs, New York.
Here, you’ll find an incredible selection of brand clothing, purses, kids’ clothes, and toys, all at unbeatable prices.
Step into our boutique and be greeted by our friendly, knowledgeable staff, always ready to assist you.
Whether you’re searching for a stylish outfit for a special occasion or just want to revamp your wardrobe on a budget, we have something for everyone.
Their shelves are stocked with high-quality items that have been carefully curated to ensure only the best pieces make it onto our racks.
From designer jeans to trendy handbags, New 2 You Fine Consignment Boutique offers a wide range of brand clothing and accessories that keep you looking fabulous without breaking the bank.
Address: 2100 Doubleday Ave, Ballston Spa, NY 12020, United States
2. Saratoga Consignment Studio
If you’re on the lookout for unique and interesting home office items, Saratoga Consignment Studio in Saratoga Springs, New York, should be your go-to place.
With a wide variety of items to browse through, this consignment shop is a treasure trove waiting to be explored.
From vintage typewriters to quirky desk organizers, they have it all.
Whether you’re looking for something practical or decorative, you’ll find plenty of options that cater to your taste and style.
One of the standout features of Saratoga Consignment Studio is its commitment to offering excellent quality furniture at fair prices.
Unlike other consignment stores that may compromise on quality, this shop ensures that every piece they sell meets high standards.
From sturdy wooden desks to comfortable office chairs, their collection boasts durability and functionality without breaking the bank.
Address: 3306 S Broadway, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866, United States
Also see our article on Tattoo Shops in New York.
Consignment Shops in Albany, New York
1. Plato’s Closet Albany
Are you a trendsetter on a budget?
Look no further than Plato’s Closet Albany – the ultimate consignment shop for fashion-forward teens and young adults.
Located conveniently in the heart of the city, this trendy store is a haven for fashion lovers who want to stay on top of the latest trends at an affordable price.
Whether you’re a college student searching for budget-friendly wardrobe essentials or a fashion-forward individual wanting to refresh your closet with unique finds, Plato’s Closet has got you covered.
At Plato’s Closet Albany, they pride themselves on their carefully curated selection of gently used clothing items.
Their inventory is constantly updated with fashionable pieces from popular brands and designers at prices that will make your wallet smile.
From stylish jeans and dresses to chic tops and accessories, there is something for everyone at this consignment shop.
Address: 1770 Central Ave, Albany, NY 12205, United States
2. Polkadots Consignment Shop
Looking for a great place to save money on clothes, toys, and more?
Then Polkadots Consignment Shop must be your favorite destination.
It is a beloved local family-owned business that has been serving the Albany community for over 15 years.
Nestled in the heart of downtown Albany, this charming store has become a go-to destination for fashion-savvy individuals and budget-conscious families alike.
Polkadots Consignment Shop offers an affordable alternative to traditional retail shopping with its extensive selection of gently used items.
Whether you’re searching for trendy clothing pieces or seeking unique toys for your little ones, you’ll find it all under one roof at this hidden gem.
The shop’s longstanding presence in the community speaks volumes about its commitment to delivering high-quality products at unbeatable prices.
Besides, they have a fantastic team of staff who are always keen to assist you while shopping in their consignment store.
Address: 10 New Karner Rd, Guilderland, NY 12084, United States
Also see our article on Body Shops in New York.
Consignment Shops in Buffalo, New York
1. Hertel Home Consignment Inc.
Hertel Home Consignment Inc. is the go-to consignment shop in Buffalo, New York, for those seeking great furniture at reasonable prices.
With a wide selection of high-end furniture and home accents, this store is a treasure trove for interior design enthusiasts on a budget.
From elegant sofas to unique statement pieces, Hertel offers an impressive collection that promises to elevate any living space.
What sets Hertel Home Consignment apart is not just their exceptional inventory but also its helpful staff.
The team at this consignment shop understands the importance of finding the perfect piece to complete your home decor vision.
They are knowledgeable about each item in stock and can provide valuable advice on how to incorporate it into your existing aesthetic.
Whether you’re looking for a specific style or need assistance with measurements, their friendly and attentive assistance will ensure you make the best choice for your home.
Address: 1390 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216, United States
2. Maasai Consignnent Boutique
Maasai Consignment Boutique: A Hidden Gem for Quality Furniture, Antiques & Home Goods
If you’re on the lookout for unique and high-quality furniture, antiques, or home goods in Buffalo, New York, look no further than Maasai Consignment Boutique.
Specializing in consignment furniture, this boutique offers an impressive collection of hand-picked items that will add charm and character to any space.
With a focus on providing customers with top-notch products, Maasai prides itself on being a go-to destination for those seeking stylish and timeless pieces.
They meticulously curate a selection of furniture, antiques, and home goods that are visually stunning and built to last.
So, whether you’re searching for a vintage dresser or an elegant dining table set, you can trust that each piece has been carefully inspected for its craftsmanship and condition.
Address: 208 E Delavan Ave, Buffalo, NY 14208, United States
3. Scoop Shop
For over eight decades, Scoop Shop has been a beloved fixture in the vibrant city of Buffalo, New York.
Established in 1937, it proudly holds the title of Buffalo’s oldest consignment clothing store.
With a rich history and an extensive collection of classic and vintage clothes and jewelry, Scoop Shop is a treasure trove for fashion enthusiasts looking to add timeless pieces to their wardrobes.
However, walking into Scoop Shop is like stepping back in time.
The store exudes an old-world charm that instantly transports visitors to a bygone era.
From elegant dresses to tailored suits, every item tells a story and carries the essence of its previous owners.
The dedicated team behind this local business carefully hand-picks each item to ensure it meets their standards of style and condition.
Address: 648 Auburn Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, United States
4. Second Chic
Second Chic, the premier consignment shop in Buffalo, New York, is a haven for fashion-forward individuals looking to score stylish pieces at affordable prices.
With its extensive collection of gently used clothing, shoes, jewelry, and other accessories, Second Chic offers a unique shopping experience that combines high-quality items with budget-friendly options.
As soon as you step into the store, you’ll be greeted by racks filled with carefully curated pieces neatly tagged with their corresponding price and size information.
This attention to detail ensures that customers can easily browse the store’s inventory and find exactly what they want.
One of the standout features of Second Chic is its dedicated dressing rooms.
These private spaces allow shoppers to try on their finds before making a purchase.
The spacious and well-lit dressing rooms are equipped with full-length mirrors, giving customers a chance to see how each garment fits and flatters their body shape.
Address: 810 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, United States
Also see our article on Tire Shops in New York.
Consignment Shops in Rochester, New York
1. Brighton Your Bump
Brighton Your Bump, a charming boutique-style consignment shop nestled in the heart of Rochester, is every expectant mother’s dream destination.
With a wide array of options available, from everyday essentials to specialty items such as bras, swimsuits, and nursing clothes, this consignment store has you covered throughout your pregnancy journey.
Brighton Your Bump has everything if you’re seeking stylish clothing or practical items for your little one.
One of the standout features of this consignment store is its impressive range of products – they truly have a good selection of everything.
From fashionable dresses and tops to comfortable leggings and jeans, their maternity collection ensures that expecting moms can embrace their style without sacrificing comfort.
Furthermore, Brighton Your Bump goes above and beyond by offering an extensive range of sizes, accommodating women at any stage of pregnancy.
Address: 1551 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
2. Duds For Love Bugs
Are you looking for a one-stop shop to satisfy your children’s ever-changing toy preferences at an affordable price?
Then look no further than Duds For Love Bugs, a seasonal, semi-annual children’s “pop-up” consignment sale in the heart of Rochester, New York.
With an extensive and well-organized selection of children’s clothes and toys, this consignment shop is every parent’s dream come true.
Whether your little one is into building blocks, dolls, puzzles, or action figures, Duds For Love Bugs has it all.
Even you will get a ton of various brands of high-quality clothes for your child.
Their carefully curated collection ensures that you will always find something to pique your little one’s interest.
From educational toys that promote cognitive development to the latest trending gadgets on the market, this consignment sale has something for children of all ages and interests.
Address: 1200 Edgewood Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
3. Panache Vintage & Finer Consignment
Since its establishment in 2010, Panache Vintage & Finer Consignment has become a go-to destination for fashion enthusiasts seeking unique and timeless pieces.
Quickly it has become one of the favorite places for the city’s locals and visitors.
This consignment shop in the heart of Rochester offers an extensive collection ranging from vintage clothing and handbags to shoes, jewelry, and even furs.
With its exceptional staff and unparalleled service, Panache Vintage has earned a reputation as one of the best consignment shops in the area.
When you enter Panache Vintage & Finer Consignment, you are transported to a world of elegance and charm.
Its carefully curated selection sets Panache Vintage apart from other consignment stores.
Their knowledgeable staff handpicked Every item on display, ensuring only the finest quality pieces make it onto their shelves.
Address: 1855 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
If you liked this article, you may also like to read about the best Flower Shops, Pet Stores, and Barber Shops in New York.
Looking beyond New York? Check out our article on the best Consignment Shops in Texas and Illinois.