23 Thrift Stores in NEW YORK (Unique, Affordable & Sturdy)
“Work better, spend wiser,” as the popular phrase goes.
Going through several years of instability and seeing how inflation affects every home on Earth is undoubtedly quite concerning.
In times like these, spending wisely is the only way to get through the day with still some amount left in your pockets.
One of the smartest things to spend money on is something that is neither vital nor necessary.
If you truly need a certain thing, see if there is a cheaper option of high quality.
A thrift store is an excellent place to locate amazing products that have been used but remain useful and are in high condition and shape for a much lower price.
There are many fantastic secondhand stores in New York, and here are a few to get you started.
And by the way, you may also want to check out the best Consignment Shops in New York.
Thrift Stores in Rochester, New York
1. Rochester Greenovation
People have varied preferences; thus, it is natural that a person is not likely to be a fan of a thrift store or could not even touch an item from a thrift store.
There are thrift stores with products that are not entirely worn out, are still visible, or appear to have never been used or touched due to their outstanding quality.
Rochester Greenovation is a thrift store similar to this one.
It is not your typical thrift store; it offers used products.
However, before they are shown for sale, they go through an upcycling method in which the items are developed and entirely transformed to seem original.
Many people enjoy visiting Rochester Greenovation because of the high quality of goods, and the business has flash sales of up to 70% off on Thursdays till 8 p.m.
A lower price for a lot lower price, that’s incredible.
The Rochester Greenovation has moved to an improved spot along Flint Street; this new location has a larger and broader space, which is far better for clients.
Address: 850 Saint Paul St Ste 14 Rochester, NY 14605
2. The OP Shop
Independent designer products, such as locally manufactured dresses, handcrafted, designed gowns, and other household items, may now be purchased at much lower prices.
There are thrift stores that sell local goods and original items from small and emerging designers, which is a great way to support the community.
A prime example of such a thrift shop is the popular Op Shop.
The Op Shop is a symbol of sustainability combined with unity, and it is easily accessible and located on Charlotte Street.
Its major purpose is to give homemade vendors a place to market their wares, particularly those highly traditional, old, and handcrafted.
Currently, there are roughly 30 sellers involved with the Op shop.
Many people shop at secondhand stores like the Op Shop because the quality is excellent, and shoppers can demonstrate their support for local manufacturers by purchasing the products.
Address: 89 Charlotte St, Rochester, NY 14607
3. Goodwill Rochester
A well-known and popular secondhand store can be found on Jefferson’s main street.
The Goodwill Rochester charity store is renowned for offering products at affordable prices that may still be used multiple times.
Goodwill has various locations in Rochester, New York, and the United States.
This secondhand business became popular because, as the name implies, a portion of Goodwill’s profits are donated to charity.
Many individuals praised the objective since purchasing an item in good condition while also understanding that it leads to doing a good deed is something worth doing and supporting.
Items are not sold or marked individually at Goodwill clearance centers, and the products are weighed and priced per pound when sold here.
It is an excellent approach to ensure that every item is sold and that the consumer keeps money since they purchase items at a low cost.
Clothing such as coats, slacks, shirts, skirts, and jackets can be found in a Goodwill clearance center, as well as living room furniture, kitchen equipment, house decorations, and personal accessories.
Address: 1555 Jefferson Rd, Rochester, NY 14623
4. AMVETS
It is always important to shop around to locate better discounts while knowing that the earnings will go to needy individuals.
There are thrift stores in the United States that specialize in assisting those in need based on a proportion of their income, such as the AMVETS thrift stores.
AMVETS Thrift Stores are also available in several states, unique thrift stores that veterans own.
A percentage of the proceeds will be donated to veterans needing financial assistance.
Because of the store’s strong mission, many individuals support AMVETS thrift stores.
There are several ways to help, including purchasing products.
If you have excess goods you no longer use and are still in excellent condition, you may donate them to the AMVETS thrift store.
The AMVETS thrift store is an ideal place to contribute since it provides opportunities to various people by offering jobs and outreach initiatives to underserved communities.
Address: 400 Jefferson Rd, Rochester, NY 14623
5. A Second Thought Retail
Many may argue that buying used products could be better and more sanitary.
Still, the idea is great if you can save significant money by purchasing them from secondhand retailers.
This thrift store business wants individuals to attain the same goal or notion as the A Second Thought Retail Shop.
The term demonstrates how vital and prudent it is to think twice before acquiring an item.
It is critical to consider whether your pay is worth the item’s value.
The Second Thought Retail Shop is easily accessible from West Commercial Street.
When you visit A Second Thought Retail Shop, you will find a great range of gently used clothes for all ages, accessories, books, furniture, and other household equipment in good condition at a fraction of the cost.
It is also ideal for shopping at this secondhand store since a portion of the sales benefits charities such as Heritage Christian Services for children needing wheelchairs.
There is also no need to be concerned because things are routinely replaced.
If you want to help or support, you may do so in three ways: purchasing products, giving excellent condition items, or volunteering for operational tasks.
Address: 349 W Commercial St # 1800, East Rochester, NY 14445
6. VigsDigs
If you want to buy less expensive furniture with attractive designs but avoid going to thrift stores, here is the place to go.
The VigsDigs furniture shop on Rochester’s main street is a rapidly growing furniture business and a thrift store.
Only some charity stores should have a lot of used clothes lined up in one part, used shoes in another, used bags and accessories in another, and home products in another, and the space should have a stale and old scent.
There are thrift stores that appear so proper and respectable that they are no longer recognized as thrift stores.
The VigsDigs furniture store is a nice example of this since it is also a thrift store since every item they sell was previously used and sold to them.
Still, the aim is to refurbish and remodel the thing to look fresher and have a different appearance while still being offered at a reasonable price.
One pro about purchasing furniture from businesses such as VigsDigs is that the design is highly unique, and you only have that one design because it was legitimately developed by VigsDigs.
You can also be confident that the quality of items is long-lasting and sturdy since VigsDigs improves the store’s reputation to ensure that it is renowned and trustworthy.
Only some thrift stores accomplish this, so purchasing from a business like VigsDigs is unique.
Address: 1237 Main St E Rochester, NY 14609
Also see our article on Book Stores in New York.
Thrift Stores in Syracuse, New York
1. Cluttered Closet
Suppose you are seeking affordable and high-quality secondhand items from a trustworthy and dependable outlet regarding hygiene.
In that case, a prominent thrift shop exists in Syracuse, New York.
The Cluttered Closet is one of the reliable thrift shops in the Syracuse area that is widely recognized to be visited by many people.
It is open Tuesday through Saturday but is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
The Cluttered Closet is located along Beech St. and is quite simple to find, with lots of parking.
This thrift shop has a wide variety of products for sale, including clothing, shoes, purses, accessories, and kitchen utilities and appliances.
The goal of the Cluttered Closet is to reduce the number of items going to the landfill by recycling various things that can still be reconditioned and sold.
You may contribute to the products offered at the Cluttered Closet by donating items that you believe are still in excellent condition and can be worn, utilized, and designed in various homes.
It is prudent to acquire products from thrift stores such as Cluttered Closet since you know you are spending for an item you will sometimes use for a very low cost, which is crucial nowadays.
Address: 742 S Beech St, Syracuse, NY 13210
2. 3fifteen
If you buy or like to buy products from thrift stores, this only sometimes implies purchasing a low-quality item.
Several thrift shops provide products with brands, and those brands are big names.
It might be clothing, purses, shoes, or other personal stuff.
Just because you purchase something at a thrift store doesn’t imply it’s bad quality and inexpensive; sometimes it’s great quality but at a lower price.
The 3fifteen thrift store on Grand Avenue in Syracuse is an excellent example of this type of store.
It is your go-to boutique for high-quality things such as dresses, shirts, purses, and shoes that are secondhand but still in good condition for further usage, as well as those that are branded.
Many people support the 3fifteen thrift store since the main goal is to extend the life of objects that can still be useful.
Some people discard excellent quality items, so thrift shops are more than glad to collect those products and sell them to others who can use them again.
It does not imply that it is recycling and generating money from other people’s things, but it does mean that items are not being added to landfills, which helps the environment.
The 3fifteen thrift shop is a wonderful shop to support since its goal and target is to aid and provide for individuals who do not have enough money to maintain their daily life, who are people in central New York.
It contributes a portion of sales or, if not, the full money to needy people.
Address: 720 University Ave, Syracuse, NY 13210
3. EcoChic Boutique
Many people support various thrift stores to contribute to the goal and stabilize financially due to the current inflation.
The EcoChic boutique thrift shop in Syracuse is one of the finest thrift shops to patronize.
It is aimed at those who are both economically cautious and concerned about the environment.
Purchasing from EcoChic Boutique ensures that you are helping the environment since the products that would otherwise be thrown away are recycled and sold through thrift stores.
A good example is branded good quality secondhand shirts and bags that can be resold for less.
The EcoChic Boutique encourages individuals to try shopping at thrift stores since the products found, particularly at independent thrift stores, are clean, in good form, safe to reuse, and highly attractive.
One of the nice things about the EcoChic Boutique is that it is unlike other thrift stores because of its carefully chosen products and styles.
Branded shirts, skirts, handcrafted purses, and even jewelry are among this shop’s high-quality things.
Address: 314 E Genesee St, Dewitt, NY 13214 (10mins. from Syracuse)
4. The Cherry Pit
Every thrift store is the same in one way: all offer products already used by someone else.
However, only some thrift shops are the same, and this is dependent on the products offered; a good example is the Cherry Tip thrift store.
The Cherry Tip Thrift Store is located at the bottom of Salina St. and is easy to find.
It stands apart from other thrift stores since it sells historical, traditional, and vintage clothing and accessories.
Many individuals immediately fell in love with this secondhand store’s offer since it is unusual to find, and the trend of wearing vintage products is popular nowadays.
The Cherry Tip thrift store frequently promotes ongoing and forthcoming events in their shop on Facebook, and those events are the mega sale where the low rate will still be accessible.
It is stylish, easily accessible, up-to-date, and fashionable, which is why many people enjoy supporting the Cherry Tip thrift store.
Address: 217 S Salina St, Downtown, Syracuse, New York 13202
5. Thrifty Shopper Westvale
Going through secondhand stores is like embarking on an expedition to find hidden treasures.
A trip to a thrift store is also regarded as a memorable adventure.
It is one of the key purposes of the Thrifty Shopper Westvale, a prominent thrift shop in Syracuse.
The Thrifty Shopper Westvale has many dresses, shirts, shoes, purses, accessories, housewares, culinary supplies, and bedding.
Also, when you visit Thrifty Shopper Westvale, you must be prepared to spend long hours digging deep, as if you were looking for gold or treasure.
It contains a lot of high-quality things to pick from, which will take a long time because you will need clarification about which one to acquire.
Even if the Thrifty Shopper Westvale items are in good condition and quality, the prices are quite reasonable, and you will know you are in a thrift shop.
Thrifty Shopper Westvale is a popular thrift shop in Syracuse, so plan your trip there ahead of time, especially if there is a current mega sale because people will go to great lengths to locate the greatest stuff.
Address: 2214 Genesee St, Syracuse, NY 13209
6. Serendipity Shoppe
There are many thrift stores nowadays, and most have valid purposes for their existence.
One of the reasons is giving back, which involves assisting individuals and groups with a percentage of the overall revenues of the thrift store, one of which is the Serendipity Shoppe.
Serendipity Shoppe is a popular secondhand shop in the Symphony Circle because it is unique compared to other thrift stores.
The distinction is that, unlike other thrift stores, Serendipity Shoppe does not sell or accept clothing.
It is well-known as a haven for people who enjoy shopping at thrift stores for books, jewelry, furniture, and artwork.
Because the Serendipity Store is maintained by members of the AIDS Plus non-profit organization, the proceeds from this thrift store will support individuals fighting HIV/AIDS and give more learnings about it to the community.
Address: 450 S Main St, North Syracuse, NY 13212
Also see our article on Furniture Stores in New York.
Thrift Stores in Buffalo, New York
1. Paloma Exchange
There are thrift stores that emerged from the desire to create a clothing company and the delight of giving to charity.
Paloma Exchange is one of the secondhand shops that arose from the owner’s passion for garments while scrolling through social media sites.
The business began on Instagram, but due to its popularity among locals, it was expanded to include a physical store, which is still frequently visited.
Many individuals have backed Paloma Exchange since the thrift store’s goal is to share and provide consumers with trustworthy quality items.
It is located on Grant Street and is open Tuesdays through Saturdays and closed on Sundays and Mondays.
One of the most popular aspects of the Paloma Exchange is its commitment to people to continue bringing them garments as long as the owners buy them.
Payment is made in cash to individuals who provide the products, and you may pick whether you want to get some money or earn points to buy stuff in Paloma Exchange.
Address: 363 Grant Street Buffalo, NY 14213
2. St. Vincent De Paul Society
In Buffalo, New York, there is a thrift store about doing good and having religious obligations.
The major purpose of this secondhand shop is to offer financial support to non-profit groups in need.
St. Vincent De Paul Society is a viable alternative for a thrift shop where all proceeds benefit charity and sick individuals such as those suffering from Diabetes or Cancer.
Many churches and religious organizations support the St. Vincent De Paul Society because of the notion of being able to aid diverse individuals, particularly those who are sick and require treatment.
Its administration values every contribution because many are sent and scheduled for pick up, especially if the amount is substantial.
The St. Vincent De Paul Society has multiple thrift store branches conveniently accessible in various places.
Supporting this thrift business is life-changing.
It helps many people, creates additional employment, and provides more funds for their things for sale because people donate clothing and other stuff.
Address: 1298 Main St. Buffalo, NY 14209
3. Second Chic
Prepare for a day of fun and shopping because you will fall in love with this thrift shop the moment you walk in.
Second Chic, the owners of this thrift store, use social media for advertising and generating noise to sell its thrift shop.
It is located on Buffalo’s main street, Williamsville, and immediately drew the attention of many residents.
Not only do locals like shopping at Second Chic, but others from neighboring cities drive to see what the Second Chic has to offer.
The major reason is that the garments offered at the thrift shop are advertised online and professionally modeled, much like what you see from larger companies.
Second Chic focuses on clothing and accessories that are vintage, contemporary, and odd in some way.
It is a thrift store and a consignment store that sells recycled fashion garments and accessories for men and women and brand-new products.
Address: 810 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
4. Peddler’s Market
Most thrift stores are in enclosed shops, so seeing one open and out in the open is unusual.
In Buffalo, one of the most well-known thrift stores is accessible to the public, much like a Sunday market with various merchants selling various products.
It is available in the Peddler’s Market.
Peddler’s Market is located on Elmwood Avenue and is fairly easy to discover because it is in a large open space.
Other thrift stores specialize in selling clothes, shoes, and bags, but Peddler’s Market has a diverse selection.
This thrift store has rustic, modern, vintage, old-school, old-age, prehistoric, athletic, and many more items.
It is enjoyable to buy at this site since there is a lot of stuff to select from, and the prices are quite low, so anticipate having many items to carry home with you.
Carpets, rugs, accessories, books, seats, vintage watches, motorcycles, toys, plants, and many other goods may be found here.
Address: 656 Elmwood Ave. Buffalo, NY 14222
Also see our article on Book Stores in New York.
Thrift Stores in New York City, New York
1. Cure Thrift Store
New York City is widely recognized for having the best clothing and accessories brands available across the city—even the residents of the city dress in various distinctive labels.
Even though New York City is full of high-end and fancy things, several thrift stores sell high-quality items.
The Cure Thrift Store is a prominent, secondhand store in New York City, and it has been open on 12th Street for over 20 years.
Walking inside the Cure Thrift Store, you will only notice one item on each floor since each floor is dedicated to a particular item.
The Cure Thrift Store is a thrift store that offers a large range of bags, shoes, jackets, shirts, coats, and accessories that are still in excellent condition, and some are even branded and sold at a much lower price.
This thrift store is liked by many individuals in New York City, as seen by numerous TV networks reaching out to them and including the shop in various programs promoting the store’s excellence.
All funds will be used to fund juvenile diabetes research and advocacy.
Address: 91 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003
2. Beacon’s Closet
When you mention a thrift store, everyone immediately thinks of a location that smells strongly of old garments and fabric.
Thrift stores in New York City are substantially different, even if many sell preloved clothes in a more refined setting, such as the Beacon’s Closet.
The Beacon’s Closet is unlike your typical secondhand store in New York City because its brand is well-known among locals and visitors who have visited its website.
Its website is fantastic since it already matches the standard quality of a website for a large trademark brand based in New York.
Beacon’s Closet offers sunglasses, purses, sneakers, accessories, jackets, coats, and hats.
Every item provided is secondhand, and some are brand new, but you can be certain that it is almost as good as new due to how the Beacon’s Closet repurposes and enhances things.
Address: 10 W 13th St, New York, NY 10011
3. Mother of Junk
Only some people in New York City look for products from large companies or with trademark labels on them.
Many individuals are still interested in high-quality products that can be purchased at a lower cost, which can undoubtedly be found at the Mother of Junk thrift store.
Mother of Junk has two sites, one on Union Avenue and one on Driggs Avenue.
When you approach the Mother of Junk location, you can immediately identify it since there are objects for sale in the store that are displayed outside the doors.
People say that among the nicest findings in Mother of Junk include chairs and tables that are still durable and fresh, as well as excellent quality coat racks and other vintage objects.
This thrift store is called the Mother of Junk not because it is all waste but because, according to the owners, everything must go and be sold, which is also why the prices at the thrift shop are so cheap and significantly lower than other shops.
Address: 567 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Also see our article on Tattoo Shops in New York.
Thrift Stores in New Hartford, New York
1. Leggs Diamond
Are you interested in thrift stores that sell products not typically seen in thrift stores?
If you live in New Hartford and have the time to scout products in numerous thrift shops, this one-of-a-kind thrift shop is the place to go.
The Leggs Diamond thrift store is located on the Seneca Turnpike.
Leggs Diamond is less loud than other big thrift stores because it is individually owned, and the products available here differ.
Some of the items you can find in Leggs Diamond include; Jewelry, whether gold, silver, or platinum, pearl and diamond, audio/visual equipment, gaming consoles, motorcycles and bikes, and collectibles such as distinctive furnishings, statues, decorations, and souvenirs.
You will have a great time browsing the various items in Leggs Diamond because, for a lower price, you can already purchase very expensive items in branded stores, which is a good thing.
After all, this thrift store’s owners ensure that the items sold here are ready to use and long-lasting.
Address: 8439 Seneca Turnpike, New Hartford, NY 13413
2. The Village Basement
Many people love visiting thrift stores because of the significant discounts that can be made while acquiring products that are in excellent condition and ready to use.
The Village Basement is a prominent, secondhand store that is quite simple but provides products that seem brand new.
It presents a particular image since a woman owns it, and it is widely assumed that when a woman runs a business, everything is well-organized.
When it comes to possessions, a woman is certain to take care of and keep everything.
Many individuals have demonstrated that everything in The Village Basement is totally in class A grade due to how it appears, how clean the products are, and that there is no stench.
The Village Basement has an Instagram account where the owner posts new arrivals that are tastefully displayed to entice loyal consumers to rush to the store.
Its prices are totally fair and well worth the value.
Address: 70 Genesee St, New Hartford, NY 13413
Also see our article on Body Shops in New York.
Thrift Stores in Yorkville, New York
1. The Queen’s Closet
People are accustomed to thrift stores that sell derivative products like shirts, belts, shoes, pants, and bags that are good for a few usage times and rely on how properly the person uses them.
There are thrift stores that sell branded things at a lesser rate and specialist items.
The Queen’s Closet is a specialty thrift store located in the city of Yorkville.
This complete thrift store can be found on Oriskany Blvd. Because The Queen’s Closet specializes in selling stuff from real estate properties, it is a favorite of many residents and those from surrounding cities.
The things left by homeowners are the ones that The Queen’s Closet prices and then posts for sale online.
There is also a shop for The Queen’s Closet where you can look for clothing, purses, and shoes, but because this thrift store specializes in large goods from real estate, it attracts the most interest.
Household objects include cupboards, table and chair sets, closets, racks, and kitchen furnishings.
Address: 22 Oriskany Blvd, Yorkville, NY 13495
2. The Housing Works – Yorkville
Many thrift stores exist for one major reason: to make money for others.
The owners already have a definite objective to support individuals in need, whether financially or through work.
Yorkville’s Housing Works is one of the secondhand stores with that sort of objective.
Housing Works is a major organization that operates thrift shops and bookstores.
Its thrift store sells high-quality, long-lasting furniture such as living room sets, tables, chairs, closets, and cupboards.
Every employee at Housing Works is beginning from scratch, meaning they are looking for work, and the revenue from the thrift shop sales goes to NGOs and medical groups for HIV/AIDS research and treatment.
Housing Works is well-known for significantly supporting eliminating the HIV/AIDS pandemic via corporate profits and assisting activists in their battle against discrimination.
Donating is also possible if you can purchase the things or live a short distance away from the place.
Address: 1730 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128 ( 10mins. from Yorkville )
If you liked this article, you may also like to read about the best Boutiques, Hobby Shops, and Yarn Shops in New York.
Looking beyond New York? Check out our article on the best Thrift Stores in Texas.